1987-01-05 CC MinutesCITY OF FARMERS BRANCH
CITY COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING
01/05/87
COUNCIL CHAMBER
POLICE BUILDING
7:30 P.M.
The following members of the City Council were present:
Mayor
Mayor Pro Tem
Councilmembers
John D. Dodd
John Dunagan
Carol Dingman
Bob Phelps
Herb Weidinger
The following member of the City Council was absent:
Councilman
Dave Blair
The following members of the City Administration were present:
Acting City Manager
Assistant City Manager
Assistant to City Attorney
City Secretary
Director of Community Services
Director of Public Works
Traffic Engineer
City Engineer
Marketing Director
Secretary
Gene Carlton
Steve Carpenter
Toby Barthelow
Randall Mahaffey
Tom Scales
Earl Deland
Larry Cervenka
Jerry Murawski
Charlie McIlvain
Ruth Ann Parish
Mayor Dodd called the City Council Meeting of 01/05/87
to order at 7:30 p.m. The meeting was televised.
A.1 INVOCATION
Councilman Bob Phelps gave the invocation and led the Pledge of
Allegiance.
A.2 PRESENTATION OF BEAUTIFICATION AWARD TO THE PARKS AND
RECREATION DEPARTMENT FROM THE MEN'S GARDEN CLUB OF
Vol. 51, Page 1
DALLAS.
Mayor Dodd explained that the Men's Garden Club of Dallas wishes to
present the Parks and Recreation Department with a Beautification
Award for its outstanding horticultural achievements during the
last year.
Mr. Hunter McKay, 3528 Cloverdale Lane, Southwest Regional
President of the Men's Garden Clubs of America, presented a
beautification award in recognition of outstanding horticultural
achievements to the Parks and Recreation Department of the City of
Farmers Branch. John Burke, Director of the Parks and Recreation
Department, was present to accept the award.
A.3 CONSIDER ACCEPTANCE OF DONATION OF RECORDS AND TAPES
FROM MR. A. H. PARSONS FOR USE IN THE SENIOR ADULT
ACTIVITY CENTER.
Mayor Dodd explained that Mr. A. H. Parsons would like to donate 23
records and two tapes for use in the Senior Adult Activity Center.
These items will be used during dance and exercise classes and for
listening enjoyment. These items are estimated to value $150.00.
John Burke, Parks and Recreation Department Director was asked to
make the presentation for Mr. Parsons.
Councilman Dunagan made the motion to accept the gift of 23
records and 2 tapes donated by Mr. A. H. Parsons to the Senior
Adult Activity Center. Councilman Weidinger seconded the motion
and all voted "aye".
A.4 PRESENTATION OF LANDSCAPE AWARD OF THE YEAR.
Mayor Dodd explained that this program initiated this year will
honor businesses or citizens for significant contributions made in
landscaping their property in order to make Farmers Branch a more
beautiful city.
This year's recipient not only has contributed many, many improve-
ments to the City of Farmers Branch, but also has one of the best
programs in the country for maintaining and beautifying its
grounds and facilities.
The Farmers Branch City Council proudly honored the Centre
Development Company as the 1986 Beautification Recipient.
Mayor Dodd presented a plaque to Frank Ventura and Meg Gibbs who
were present and represented the Centre Development Company.
A.5
PRESENTATION OF SERVICE AWARD
Vol. 51, Page 2
Mayor Dodd presented Ron O'Burke of the Fire Department with a 5
year employee service award.
A.6 PRESENTATION OF BOARD APPLICATIONS.
Mayor Dodd explained that this item gives applicants an opportunity
to present board applications to the City Council.
Ken Rymer, 3301 Scarlet Oak, came forward to present his
application to serve on the Parks & Recreation Board. Mr. Rymer
has been a resident of the City of Farmers Branch for four years.
Councilwoman Dingman reminded everyone that Mr. Ken Rymer is the
citizen who maintained the median in front of his home for several
years.
CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING AS CONSENT ITEMS AND TAKE
THE APPROPRIATE ACTION. ITEMS B.1 TO B.3.
Mayor Dodd explained that under the title of consent items
are items that are to be considered and action taken that
may not need discussion individually. Any member of the
City Council or the audience may request to withdraw
any item from the consent items and place the item before
the Council for full discussion. The concept for the con-
sent items is being established in order to speed up
discussion for those items that need more time for
discussion.
Councilman Dunagan commented that there were some corrections made
to the minutes of the December 22, 1986, Regular Council Meeting.
Those corrections have been made and distributed to the Council.
Councilman Dunagan made the motion to approve the following consent
items: B.1, B.2 and B.3. Councilman Phelps seconded the motion and
all voted "aye".
B.1 APPROVED MINUTES OF EXECUTIVE SESSION OF
DECEMBER 8, 1986.
B.2 APPROVED MINUTES OF EXECUTIVE SESSION OF
DECEMBER 22, 1986.
B.3 APPROVED MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING OF DECEMBER 22,
1986.
C.1 CITY MANAGER REPORTS.
Vol. 51, Page 3
Acting City Manager Gene Carlton gave an informative report on the
programs, projects and happenings of the various departments of the
City.
C.2 PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER REQUEST OF PARK WEST C3
ASSOCIATES FOR A SPECIFIC USE PERMIT TO OPERATE A
RESTAURANT WITH A MIXED BEVERAGE PERMIT AT THE
NORTHWEST CORNER OF LUNA ROAD AND LBJ FREEWAY BEING
LOCATED IN PLANNED DEVELOPMENT 22 ZONING DISTRICT
AND TAKE THE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Dodd opened the Public Hearing.
Mayor Dodd explained that Park West C3 Associates is requesting a
Specific Use Permit for a Restaurant with a Mixed Beverage Permit
to be located in the existing 7 story office building at 1503
L.B.J. The proposed restaurant will be on the ground floor and
meets all the requirements of ordinance 1652 - the Alcohol Zoning
Ordinance.
Mr. Michael Tucker, 1509 LBJ Freeway, Vice President of Cadillac
Fairview Urban Development, Inc., came forward seeking a Specific
Use Permit for a restaurant located in their newest office
building. This restaurant would have a Mixed Beverage Permit. Mr.
Tucker feels the organization would be bringing to Farmers Branch a
very high quality restaurant that complies to all aspects of the
mixed beverage ordinance.
Councilman Weidinger made the motion to close the public hearing.
Councilman Phelps seconded the motion. All voted "aye".
Councilman Phelps commented that during the Study Session the
question of the cost per square foot of the restaurant was brought
up. Mr. Tucker stated the restaurant is still in the design stage
but the cost is somewhere between $90 and $100 per square foot.
Councilman Weidinger asked Mr. Tucker the name of the restaurant.
Mr. Tucker said the name of the restaurant is the Pacific Street
Grill at Parkwest. He stated this would be the second restaurant
of its type in the Metropolitan area. The other one is in the
Pacific Place office building in downtown Dallas. The theme for
the restaurant is an upscaled New Orleans seafood restaurant and
grill. It is approximately 5400 square feet. Councilwoman Dingman
asked who would be operating the restaurant. Mr. Tucker said
Kendron and Company would be the tenants and would be operating the
restaurant. This is the same company which operates the restaurant
in downtown Dallas.
Councilman Dunagan made a motion
to approve the
request by
Cadillac
Fairview Urban Development, Inc.,
for a Special
Use Permit
for a
Vol. 51, Page 4
restaurant with a mixed beverage permit located in the 7 story
office building at 1503 L.B.J. Freeway as recommended by the
Planning and Zoning Commission. Councilwoman Dingman seconded the
motion and all voted "aye".
C.3 PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER REQUEST OF W. BRENT THOMPSON
FOR A ZONING CHANGE FROM OFFICE TO COMMERCIAL WITH A
SPECIFIC USE PERMIT FOR AN AUTO REPAIR GARAGE ON A .52
ACRE TRACT OF LAND LOCATED APPROXIMATELY 500 FEET EAST
OF JOSEY LANE AND 136 FEET NORTH OF VALWOOD PARKWAY AND
TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Dodd opened the public hearing.
Mayor Dodd explained that Mr. Thompson owns a tract of land on the
north side of Valwood Parkway. It is currently zoned Office.
Office zoning will not allow an auto repair garage. Mr. Thompson
would like to place an auto repair garage on 0.52 acres of the
tract and therefore is requesting a zoning change to Commercial
with a Specific Use Permit for the auto repair garage.
Owners of more than 20% (26.7%) of the property within two hundred
(200) feet of the site have returned letters opposing the request
and therefore the zoning ordinance requires a 3/4 favorable vote
from the City Council to approve the zoning change.
Mayor Dodd explained that the Planning and Zoning Commission, by
unanimous vote, recommends this request be denied.
Mr. Hoyt Arnold, 2882 Mark Twain, asked the question "If the
Planing and Zoning Committee has already turned this down, why is
the Council still considering this?". Mayor Dodd explained that
the Planning and Zoning Commission only makes their recommendation
to the City Council.
Mr. Rex Williams, 12450 Wood Manor Circle, came forward to speak in
behalf of Valwood Park Baptist Church in opposition to the zoning
change. Mr. Williams is a member of the church and a designated
trustee. Mr. Williams represents his fellow church members in
feeling that the church property would be of less value if the
zoning was changed to commercial and the auto repair garage was
able to go in. Also, the church members feel the auto repair
garage would not help the city be a more beautiful Farmers Branch.
Mr. W. Brent Thompson, 2755 Valwood, was present and came forward
to represent the proposed Auto Repair Garage. He stated that the
three objections the Planning and Zoning commission have with the
project are: (1) it was seen as spot zoning, (2) parking,
particularly the overnight storage; and (3) it is an auto repair
facility. Mr. Thompson stated all of the zoning ordinances and the
Vol. 51, Page 5
requirements that
brick so it could
future.
Councilman Weidini
Councilman Phelps
were made have been met. The building would be
be used for other types of businesses in the
jer made the motion to close the Public Hearing.
seconded the motion and all voted "aye".
Councilman Weidinger asked if the building would have lease
restrictions on what type of business could go into the building at
a later date. Mr. Thompson said the building would have lease
restrictions placed upon it by the Planning and Zoning Commission.
Councilman Phelps asked for an explanation of how a special use
permit can revert back to the original zoning. Tom Scales,
Director of Community Services, commented that as long as the
person who applied for the Specific Use Permit is using it and has
not abandoned the property, the zoning change will remain the same.
However, if the owner does abandon the property and is not using
the Specific Use Permit, the zoning will revert back to the type of
zoning before the change occurred.
Mr. Thompson pointed out various properties in the area and their
uses. He stated that some of the uses were in violation according
to the City ordinances.
Councilwoman Dingman explained the difference between spot zoning
and the Specific Use Permit. The Specific Use Permit lets the
Council and Planning and Zoning take a closer look at the use for
that particular zoning category. Then a determination is made
whether that particular use of the property is a good use for that
zoning area. Mr. Thompson is asking for a zoning change along with
a Specific Use Permit which is spot zoning.
Councilwoman Dingman made the motion to follow the recommendation
of the Planning and Zoning Commission and deny the request for the
zoning change from Office to Commercial and deny issuance of a
Specific Use Permit for an auto repair garage located approximately
500 feet east of Josey Lane and 136 feet north of Valwood Parkway.
Councilman Weidinger seconded the motion and all voted "aye"
Mr. Thompson requested that under the zoning ordinance and the
designations of the Zoning Board of Adjustments that the City of
Farmers Branch act under 21-103 to correct the items that he put on
record tonight as to the violations of said ordinances. Mayor Dodd
asked that Mr. Thompson put that request in letter form.
C.4 PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER REQUEST OF MTR PROPERTIES FOR
A SPECIFIC USE PERMIT FOR AN OIL CHANGE AND LUBE CENTER
IN CONJUNCTION WITH AN EXISTING FULL SERVICE CARWASH
Vol. 51, Page 6
[1
AND SERVICE STATION FACILITY ON A 1.7374 ACRE TRACT OF
LAND LOCATED AT 3336 BELTLINE ROAD AND ADJACENT TO THE
EAST PROPERTY LINE OF KIP'S BIG BOY RESTAURANT AND IN A
LIGHT INDUSTRIAL ZONING DISTRICT AND TAKE APPROPRIATE
ACTION.
Mayor Dodd opened the Public Hearing.
Mayor Dodd explained that MTR Properties, the operator of Ultra Car
Wash, is requesting a Specific Use Permit to operate an Oil Change
and Lube Center within an existing structure noted as "Detail Clean
& Wax" on the site plan and located at the southwest corner of the
lot. A Specific Use Permit is required for an Oil Change and Lube
Center in a Light Industrial Zoning District.
The Planning and Zoning Commission, by a 6 to 1 vote, recommended
the SUP be approved.
No one came forward to speak for or against the item so Mayor Dodd
called for a motion to close the Public Hearing.
Councilman Weidinger made the motion to close the Public Hearing.
Councilman Phelps seconded the motion and all voted "aye".
Mr. William Fajardo came forward to represent Ultra Car Wash.
Councilman Phelps asked if this is going to be part of a building
that is already at this location. Mr. Fajardo said Ultra Car Wash
would be in a modified area of a building that is already there.
Two bays of an auto detail shop would be turned into an oil change
and lube center area.
Councilman Weidinger made the motion to approve the Specific Use
Permit requested by Ultra Car Wash as recommended by the Planning
and Zoning Commission. Councilman Dunagan seconded the motion and
all voted "aye". W. I(06o
C.5 SITE PLAN: CONSIDER REQUEST OF CENTRE DEVELOPMENT CO.
INC. FOR APPROVAL OF A SITE PLAN ON A 4.28 ACRE TRACT
OF LAND LOCATED EAST OF SENLAC ON DIPLOMAT DRIVE IN
PLANNED DEVELOPMENT 22 ZONING DISTRICT AND TAKE
APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Centre Development Co. has requested to withdraw this item at this
time and bring it back before the Council at another time. The
recommendation was made during the Study Session to table the item.
Councilman Weidinger made the motion to table Item C.5.
Councilwoman Dingman seconded the motion and all voted "aye".
Vol. 51, Page 7
C.6 CONSIDER ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 87-001 RELATIVE TO THE
PROCESSING OF BUILDING PERMITS AND FLOODPLAIN PERMITS
WITHIN FARMERS BRANCH CREEK DRAINAGE BASIN AND TAKE
APPROPRIATE ACTION
Mayor Dodd explained that until the FEMA Study of the Farmers
Branch Creek Drainage Basin is completed, an ordinance is required
to put a hold on issuances of building permits and fill permits in
or contiguous to the floodplain of this creek.
In emergency situations where life and property are in jeopardy,
the Engineering Department may recommend to the Council that a
fill permit be issued.
Development plans subsequent to plat and replat approval within
the watershed of Farmers Branch Creek will be subject to engineer-
ing evaluation pertinent to the stormwater management program
of Farmers Branch Creek and will be required to provide detention/
retention of stormwater runoff as directed by the Engineering
Department.
The City Engineer recommends that Resolution No. 87-001 be
adopted.
Mayor Dodd stated that the resolution had been changed as discussed
in the study session and distributed to the Council.
Vernon Smith, 2715 Bay Meadow Circle, had a question to pose to the
Council. He asked if the City has actually hired an engineering
firm to do the hydraulic study on Farmers Branch Creek. Jerry
Murawski, City Engineer, stated the Engineering Department has
selected the firm of Turner, Collie and Braden and is now
negotiating the pay with them. A contract and recommendation for
the award of a contract will be brought before the City Council at
the January 19 meeting.
Vernon Smith asked if the 30-day grace period given to the City by
the Federal Emergency Management Agency to let them know what the
City was going to do. Have we met this deadline. Jerry Murawski
stated that on New Years Eve a letter was sent to FEMA in which
FEMA was given a schedule and reinforced the City's desire to
participate in the FEMA program.
Vernon Smith asked if there is any way we can stop the building
activity in the Brookhaven area until FEMA gives their approval or
is the City going to continue issuing building permits to people
building their homes over there.
Jerry Murawski, City Engineer, said that the builders that are
building have been issued permits prior to the recent creeks issue.
Vol. 51, Page 8
Resolution No. 87-001 would stop any further issuance of building
permits in floodplain areas until the study has been completed.
Vernon Smith asked if there will be a deadline date for finishing
the hydraulic study. Also, are we going to invite Addison to
participate in upstream development in regards to damage downstream
and also Mobil's participation.
City Engineer Jerry Murawski stated as regard to timing as in the
resolution the covenants are to be enforced until the study is
complete or until July 1, 1987. With regards to participation by
Addison, the city has not talked to them about participating. The
City Engineer said he would be very hesitant to talk to Addison
about participating because there is no real reason for them to
participate. At the present time we do not know if Addison has
caused a problem or not.
Councilman Dunagan stated he has a problem with the Resolution not
allowing issuance of any more building permits in the floodplain
until after the hydraulic study had been completed.
City Engineer Jerry Murawski, stated the hydraulic study would
determine where the flood plain is. Until the flood plain is
outlined, the Engineering Department does not want to issue a
building permit to someone not knowing the outcome of the study and
that permit would be based on conjecture.
Councilman Phelps made a motion to adopt Resolution No. 87-001 as
per the amended copy that will hold the issuances of building
permits and fill permits in or contiguous to the floodplain within
Farmers Branch Creek. Councilwoman Dingman seconded the motion and
all voted "aye".
D.1 CONSIDER
ATTORNEY
OF STATE
Mayor Dodd explained
at the request of th,
Study Session.
AUTHORIZING THE CITY ATTORNEY TO REQUEST THE
GENERAL'S OPINION RELATING TO THE COLLECTION
SALES TAX.
that this item has been placed on the agenda
City Council members as discussed in the last
Toby Barthelow, representing the City Attorney, John Boyle, made a
statement regarding the collection of state sales tax. Toby
Barthelow stated there have been some sales taxes that have been
allocated to the City of Dallas that should have been allocated
to the City of Farmers Branch. The Attorney General's opinion is
that the Controller's office should go back prior to the last four
years to check the records. The Controller's office said it is too
Vol. 51, Page 9
much of a strain to keep records back that far. The recourse that
has been suggested is to seek another opinion from the Attorney
General's office. To do that we have to either have the District
Attorney or the Chairman of the Legislative Committee make a formal
request. The City Attorney's office is now proceeding to discuss
with various people the possibility of initiating a request like
that. The City Attorney recommends that the Council authorize the
City Staff and the City Attorney to proceed along those lines.
Councilman Weidinger made the motion to authorize the City Attorney
to proceed with the request for the Attorney General's opinion
relating to the collection of State Sales Tax. Councilman Phelps
seconded the motion and all voted "aye".
D.2 CONSIDER ADOPTING ORDINANCE NO. 1662 DETERMINING AND
DECLARING THE NECESSITY FOR AND ORDERING AND PROVIDING
FOR THE PAVING AND IMPROVEMENTS ON FYKE ROAD AND MAKING
PROVISION FOR LEVYING ASSESSMENTS AGAINST ABUTTING
PROPERTY AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION
Mayor Dodd explained that to abide by the legal statutes regulating
the enactment of assessment paving projects, it is necessary that
Council pass an ordinance determining and declaring the need for
the paving improvements.
The proposed ordinance provides for the City to determine and
declare the necessity for, and orders and provides for, the
paving improvements to that section of Fyke Road from Josey Lane
to Webb Chapel Road.
Mayor Dodd explained that during the Study Session, the Council
requested additional information and requested that this item be
tabled until the next Council Meeting.
Councilman Phelps made the motion to table item D.2 until the next
Council Meeting. Councilman Weidinger seconded the motion and all
voted "aye".
Councilman Dunagan made it clear to residents that in no case would
the residential properties be assessed in the Fyke Road area.
D.3 CONSIDER AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF A CONTRACT FOR
ENGINEERING SERVICES TO THE FIRM OF COTTER GOODWIN AND
MARSHALL FOR DESIGN OF A 16" WATER MAIN, CIP PROJECT
NO. 25-8603-90-01, AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION
Mayor Dodd explained that the 16" water main adjacent to the DP&L
ROW extending between Midway Road and Inwood Road is a Capital
Improvements Project currently in the approved 1985-86 program.
The design of this project should be initiated in order to begin
Vol. 51, Page 10
construction during the current CIP year. The water line
improvements have been budgeted in the amount of $500,000.00.
The firm of Cotter Goodwin and Marshall has submitted a proposal
to complete the engineering design on this project for a fee of 9%
of the actual construction cost. This fee would be a lump sum of
$27,527.40, based on a preliminary Construction Cost Estimate
of $305,860.00.
The Engineering Department recommends authorizing the execution of
a contract between the City of Farmers Branch and the firm of
Cotter Goodwin and Marshall to complete the engineering design for
a fee of $27,527.40. Because Cotter, Goodwin and Marshall does
not have professional liability insurance, the City assumes the
liability for their design.
Councilwoman Dingman asked for an explanation of the extent of the
City's liability in this project.
Jerry Murawski, City Engineer feels that the liability aspect in
this project is relatively low. The project would be checked in
three different ways by the City Staff as the project progresses.
The City feels this project is low risk and low exposure.
Councilwoman Dingman stated she would prefer the City not take
on anymore liability than it already has.
Councilman Dunagan made the motion to authorize execution of a
contract for engineering services to the firm of Cotter, Goodwin
and Marshall for design of a 1116" water main, CIP project number
25-8603-90-01 for a flat fee of $27,527.40 without the need of them
furnishing professional design liability insurance.
Councilman Phelps seconded the motion and all voted "aye".
D.4 CONSIDER AUTHORIZING CHANGE ORDER NO 1 TO AMEND THE
DESIGN CONTRACT WITH LOCKWOOD ANDREWS AND NEWNAM, INC.
TO PERFORM ADDITIONAL HYDRAULIC ANALYSIS ON RAWHIDE
CREEK AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION
Mayor Dodd explained that to evaluate the effects of the
constructed gabions along the Rawhide Creek from Tom Field Road to
Webb Chapel Road and also to be in compliance with FEMA
regulations, a hydraulic analysis shall be performed. Lockwood
Andrews and Newnam consulting firm is currently designing gabion
treatments and performing hydraulic analysis for the portion of
Rawhide Creek that is located in Oran Good Park. Their contract
fee for this erosion control project is $34,500.00. Lockwood
Andrews and Newnam has submitted their proposal to perform
additional analysis for $5,950.00. Funds available to this Oran
Good Project is $1,172,000.00.
Vol. 51, Page 11
The City Engineer recommends that the design contract with
Lockwood Andrews and Newnam, Inc. be amended in the amount
of $5,950.00 for the additional hydraulic analysis along the
Rawhide Creek from Tom Field Road to Webb Chapel Road.
Councilwoman Dingman pointed out that this change order with added
cost to the study was necessary to follow the FEMA requirements.
Councilman Weidinger so moved to authorize Change Order No. 1 to
amend the design contract with Lockwood, Andrews and Newnam, Inc.
to perform additional hydraulic analysis on Rawhide Creek.
Councilman Dunagan seconded the motion. All voted "aye".
D.5 CONSIDER AWARDING THE BID FOR A BACKHOE FOR THE WATER
MAIN REPLACEMENT DIVISION AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Dodd explained that it has been recommended by the City
Manager that the awarding of the bid for a backhoe be withdrawn so
the staff can further consider the bid.
Councilman Phelps made the motion to withdraw this item from the
agenda. Councilman Weidinger seconded the motion and all voted
"aye".
D.6 CONSIDER AWARDING THE BID FOR VALLEY VIEW MEDIAN
ENHANCEMENT AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION
Mayor Dodd explained that Valley View Median Enhancement includes
landscape and irrigation from I-35E to Mustang Trails park. The
estimated construction budget for the total project was
$400,000.00. Bids on this project were set up with a base bid and
several alternates.
There were five bids received for landscape and seven bids
received for irrigation,
Low bid for landscape was from Covington's Nursery for
$183,745.50, plus alternates 1, 2, 3, 4 and 8 for $44,902.20
for a total of $228,647.70. The Engineering Department has
extensively reviewed this bid and find no objections to it.
Low bid for irrigation was also from Covington's for $70,000.00.
Covington's has requested to withdraw their irrigation bid
because of an error their subcontractor made. Second low bid
was from Suburban Irrigation for $83,782.02. The alternates for
the irrigation is for conduit for future electrical use in the
amount of $60,780.00 for a total contract price of $144,562.02_.
The Engineering Department recommends that the landscape bid be
Vol. 51, Page 12
awarded to Covington's for $228,647.70 (including alternates)
reject low bid under advise from the City Attorney and award
the irrigation bid to second low bidder, Suburban Irrigation,
for $144,562.02 (including alternates).
Jerry Murawski, City Engineer, explained that the bid was a mix and
match type bid and also explained the extenuating circumstances and
reason for rejecting the low bid for the irrigation.
Councilman Dunagan commented that he does not feel the Council
should make a practice of letting the low bidder off but should at
some point start taking those low bids and enforcing the letter of
the law.
Councilwoman Dingman made the motion to award the landscape bid to
Covington's for $228,647.70 (including alternates), reject low bid
under the advise from the city Attorney and award the irrigation
bid to second low bidder, Suburban Irrigation, for $144,562.02
(including alternates). Councilman Weidinger seconded the motion
and all voted "aye".
D.7 CONSIDER COUNCIL TRAVEL REQUESTS AND TAKE THE
APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Dodd explained that this item is placed on each agenda to
give the Council members an opportunity to present requests.
Mayor Dodd stated that the first travel request is for the
mid-winter meeting of the U.S. Conference of Mayors, January 21,
1987 through January 23, 1987 in Washington, D.C., which the Mayor
attends. Mayor Dodd is on the Transportation and Communication
Committee and has been notified that he has been appointed to the
Membership Committee. Mayor Dodd explained the accomplishments and
benefits for his participation in this organization.
The second travel request is the National League of Cities meeting
which is held February 28, 1987 through March 3, 1987 in
Washington, D.C. The Mayor and Council members would be meeting
with various Congressmen and Senators and work on various
legislation.
Councilman Phelps made the motion to approve the travel requests of
the Mayor attending the U. S. Conference of Mayors meeting January
21 to January 23, 1987, in Washington, D.C.; and, the Mayor and
Council attending the National League of Cities Congressional City
Conference, February 28 to March 3, 1987, in Washington, D. C..
Councilman Dunagan seconded the motion and all voted "aye".
D.8 CITIZEN PARTICIPATION.
Vol. 51, Page 13
There was no one who wished to speak.
MAYOR DODD ANNOUNCES THAT THE ITEMS ON THE AGENDA OR THE GENERAL
SESSION HAVE BEEN CONCLUDED. AFTER A SHORT RECESS, THE MEETING
WILL RECONVENE FOR ITEMS IN THE EXECUTIVE SESSION. THE MEETING
WILL RECONVENE INTO GENERAL SESSION AFTER THE ITEMS HAVE BEEN
DISCUSSED IN THE EXECUTIVE SESSION. ARTICLE 6252-17, SECTION 2
OF THE OPEN MEETING LAW PROVIDES THAT SUCH ITEMS AS PERSONAL
MATTERS, LAND ACQUISITION AND PENDING AND CONTEMPLATED LITIGATION
MAY BE DISCUSSED IN CLOSED SESSION.
E.1 EXECUTIVE SESSION.
a. DISCUSS PERSONNEL MATTERS - ARTICLE 6252-17, SEC. 2(G)
A. DISCUSS APPOINTMENT TO THE PARKS AND RECREATION
BOARD.
B. DISCUSS APPOINTMENTS TO THE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
C. DISCUSS APPOINTMENTS TO FARMERS BRANCH/CARROLLTON
FLOOD CONTROL DISTRICT BOARD.
D. DISCUSS APPOINTMENT TO THE FARMERS BRANCH HOSPITAL
AUTHORITY BOARD.
E. DISCUSS APPOINTMENTS FARMERS BRANCH HISTORICAL BD.
THE COUNCIL RECONVENED INTO GENERAL SESSION
E.2 CONSIDER NECESSARY ACTION ON PERSONNEL MATTERS
DISCUSSED IN THE EXECUTIVE SESSION.
A motion by Councilman Weidinger, a second by Councilman Dunagan,
all voting "aye", appointed John Walsh to serve Place 5 on the
Farmers Branch-Carrollton Flood Control District Board of
Directors with the term to expire December 15, 1988.
F.1 ADJOURNMENT.
A motion by Councilman Weidinger, a second by Councilwoman Dingman,
a 1 voting "aye", adjourned the January 5, 1987, Council meeting at
9 4.
M vor John Dodd
City Secretary i6
Vol. 51, Page 14