2011-10-18 CC Minutes
City of Farmers Branch
City Council Meeting Minutes
City Council Chambers
13000 William Dodson Parkway
Farmers Branch, Texas
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
Regular Meeting
6:00 P.M.
City Council Chambers
The following members of the Council were present:
Mayor William P. Glancy
Mayor Pro Tem. David Koch
Deputy Mayor Pro Tem. Michelle Holmes
Council members Harold Froehlich
Ben Robinson
The following member of the City Council was absent:
Council member Tim Scott
The following members of the Administration were present:
City Manager Gary Greer
Assistant City Manager Shanna Sims-Bradish
Assistant City Manager Matt Benoit
City Secretary Cindee Peters
City Attorney Pete Smith
Finance Director Charles Cox
Director of Parks and Rec. Jeff Harting
Director of Public Works Mark Pavageaux
Director of Communications Tom Bryson
Fire Chief Steve Parker
Police Chief Sid Fuller
Director of Equipment Services Kevin Muenchow
Volume 105, page 8
B.1 INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.
Councilman Ben Robinson gave the invocation and Councilwoman Michelle Holmes led
the pledge of allegiance.
B.2 CONSIDER BOARD AND COMMISSION APPOINTMENTS AND TAKE
APPROPRIATE ACTION.
This item gives applicants an opportunity to present board applications to the City
Council and the City Council to make appointments to vacancies on boards and
commissions.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tem. Koch, a second by Councilwoman Holmes, all voting
"aye", reappointed Robert Davis, Clay Russell, Roy Morales and Jim Barrett to the Parks
and Recreation Board.
B.3 REPORT ON STUDY SESSION ITEMS.
The City Council gave a brief overview of items discussed in Study Session.
B.4 Report on items of Community Interest. Pursuant to Section 551.0415 of the Texas
Government Code the City Council may report on the following items: 1.) expression of
thanks, congratulations or condolences, 2.) information about holiday schedules, 3.)
recognition of individuals, 4.) reminders about upcoming city events, 5.) information
about community events and 6.) announcements involving an imminent threat to public
health and safety.
Mayor Glancy presented honorary citizenship to students visiting from Garbsen,
Germany.
Mayor Pro Tem. Koch reported on the great success of the Bloomin' Bluegrass festival
held last weekend.
Councilwoman Holmes thanks all of the host families for housing the students from
Garbsen, Germany. Councilwoman Holmes reported that Charles Cox has been
nominated as the Chief Financial Officer of the Year and that LBJ Express is holding
between 3 or 4 meetings a week in difference cities to update citizens on the project, and
how they support local businesses and minority owned businesses.
Councilwoman Michelle Holmes stated that on November 8, 2011 at 11 a.m. at the
Senior Center, that former Director of Parks and Recreation would be honored.
City Manager Gary Greer gave the City Manager's report.
C. CONSENT ITEMS.
Volume 105, page 9
A motion by Mayor Pro Tem Koch, a second by Councilwoman Holmes, all voting
"aye", approved the consent agenda.
C.1 APPROVED MINUTES OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF OCTOBER
3, 2011.
C.2 ADOPTED THE FOLLOWING CAPTIONED ORDINANCE NO. 3162
AMENDING SECTION 46-62, OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES BY
AMENDING THE DEFINITION OF "ILLEGAL SMOKING
PRODUCT" TO REMOVE THE CHEMICALS NOW CONTAINED IN
THE FEDERAL AND TEXAS SCHEDULES OF CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCES.
ORDINANCE NO. 3162
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH,
TEXAS AMENDING SECTION 46-62, DEFINITIONS, OF THE
CODE OF ORDINANCES BY AMENDING THE DEFINITION OF
"ILLEGAL SMOKING PRODUCT" TO REMOVE THE
CHEMICALS NOW CONTAINED IN THE FEDERAL AND
TEXAS SCHEDULES OF CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES;
PROVIDING A REPEALING CLAUSE; PROVIDING A SAVINGS
CLAUSE; PROVIDING A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE;
PROVIDING FOR PENALTY OF A FINE NOT TO EXCEED TWO
THOUSAND DOLLARS ($2,000.00); AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
C.3 APPOINTED FAYE MOSES WILKINS TO DART BOARD OF
DIRECTORS.
E.1 CONSIDER OPTIONS FOR HOLDING THE 2012 CITY COUNCIL ELECTIONS
AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Pete Smith, City Attorney, gave a brief PowerPoint explaining the 2011 Legislative
Session resulted in the passage of Senate Bill 100 that impacts municipal election dates.
This bill was passed with the intent to make the voting process easier and faster for
military and overseas voters. Absentee ballots must be transmitted no later than 45 days
before an election.
After a brief discussion, Mayor Pro Tem Koch made a motion, a second by Councilman
Robinson, all voting "aye", approved holding City elections with Dallas County in May
with 39 voting locations.
E.2 PRESENTATION ON THE DALLAS COUNTY BROOKHAVEN TRAIL PROJECT.
Volume 105, page 10
Mark Pavageaux, Director of Public Works, explained the Town of Addison has obtained
a Sustainable Development grant through the North Central Texas Council of
Governments (NCTCOG) to construct a bicycle and pedestrian trail through the
Brookhaven College campus. The project is being administered and designed by Dallas
County. The current budget is approximately $1.2 million, and will be funded by the
Sustainable Development grant and local match contributions by the Town of Addison
and Dallas County. No City of Farmers Branch funds will be utilized on the project.
The trail will connect the Brookhaven College campus with Addison's Vitruvian
development and other trail networks to the north. The trail will wind around the west
side of the college campus, and connect to the sidewalk along Valley View Lane to the
south. The trail generally fits with the City's Comprehensive Trail Plan adopted by the
City Council in October of 2010. On a regional basis the trail will connect to the Cotton
Belt Trail and Northaven Trail which are both on the Dallas County Trail Network Plan
as well as the Council of Government's Regional Veloweb (Bike Network).
Dallas County will be responsible for the design and construction of the trail. The City
will need to accept an easement from the Dallas County Community College District at a
later date. The City may also need to enter into a Project Specific Agreement with the
County after the easement has been accepted.
No action is necessary at this time.
E.3 CONSIDER ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 2011-067 AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO APPROVE THE PURCHASE OF A REPLACEMENT CITY-WIDE
VOICE-OVER IP TELEPHONE SYSTEM IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED
$235,000 AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Charles Cox, Director of Finance, explained for the past 20 years, the City has primarily
used a Nortel telephone system for telecommunication services at city facilities. Nortel
filed for bankruptcy in 2009 and subsequently ceased business. Additionally, it has
become increasingly difficult to obtain parts and service for the current system and the
City has seen increasing costs for repair and maintenance of the phone system currently
in place. This resolution provides for the purchase of a voice-over internet protocol
(VOIP) telephone system for all city facilities.
The City of Farmers Branch advertised a request for proposal for a new VOIP phone
system in July 2010 and ultimately received written proposals from five qualified
telephone system distributors, Affiliated Communications, Inc., AT&T Corporation, Co-
Nexus Communication Systems, Lantana Communications and Mercury
Communications Services, Inc. The primary goal of the city was to select an affordable,
reliable, and technologically advanced system that is easy to maintain by city staff.
Annual maintenance costs were an especially important factor as the city desired to
reduce it current maintenance costs which have been averaging $34,000 per year.
Volume 105, page 11
A voice-over internet protocol telephone system utilizes the city's internal local area
network for voice and data transmission rather than standard phone lines. This
technology allows the city to fully integrate telephone and computer technologies into a
unified communication system. This type of system combines voicemail, email, and faxes
into a user's inbox which can be readily accessed on or off site by computer, tablet or
smart phone. Phone calls can be made either with a traditional phone or Bluetooth
headset or directly from a computer. The unified communication approach provides staff.
with excellent tools necessary to communicate effectively with their customers.
City staff, with the assistance of a telephone consultant, Ben Sanford & Associates, Inc.
evaluated all proposals, attended demonstrations, contacted references and identified
Affiliated Communications' Shortel telephone system as the system best meeting the
city's goals. From a life-cycle cost standpoint, the Shortel system seven-year cost of
$298,446 was only slightly higher than the lowest life-cycle cost proposal. Shortel is
considered the third largest VOIP telephone system provider in the United States. The
initial purchase cost is $227,598 based upon request for proposal specifications. Final
costs may be slightly higher depending on ultimate features and functionality desired by
users during installation and programming. The 2011-12 adopted Fixed Asset and Fire
Station Bond budgets include a total of $235,000 for the replacement of the City's current
telephone system.
Mr. Ron Aieroli, with Mercury, suggested the Council take a more in depth look at the
winning bid, especially the maintenance costs over the next few years.
There followed a brief discussion on the new telephone system and maintenance cost
projections over the next few years.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tem Koch, a second by Councilman Robinson, all voting "aye",
approved Resolution 2011-0067 authorizing the City Manager to approve the purchase of
a city-wide voice-over IP telephone system.
EA CONSIDER ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 2011-071 AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO PURCHASE POWER OVER ETHERNET NETWORK SWITCHES
UTILIZING THE STATE OF TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION
RESOURCES CONTRACT PRICING FOR AUTOMATED INFORMATION
SYSTEMS AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Charles Cox, Director of Finance, explained the City's Wide Area Network (WAN) relies
upon a series of network switches as a foundation to connect computers, printers and
telephones together. For the network to function effectively, these switches need to be
replaced and updated on a periodic basis due to technological advances and increases in
processing and network speeds. The City's normal replacement schedule for this
equipment is every four years or as needed due to systems failure. The City last replaced
network switches over 4 years ago in 2006. This resolution provides for the purchase of
twenty-three new Cisco Catalyst Power Over Ethernet (POE) network replacement
switches.
Volume 105, page 12
The State of Texas Building and Procurement Commission (TBPC) Catalog Information
Systems Vendor (CISV) program was authorized by the State Legislature and approved
by the State of Texas Department of Information Resources (DIR) to receive competitive
catalog quotes from manufacturers and vendors of automated information systems. This
procedure allows the State to certify an entire catalog as meeting quote requirements.
Over 3,300 companies have provided catalog prices to the State. Purchasing efficiencies
result from not having to individually quote or bid out the tremendous variety of
automated information systems offered for sale. This catalog purchasing procedure is
available to local government members of the TBPC; the City of Farmers Branch is a
member. Local governments can therefore take advantage of the volume discounts
associated with large contracts.
Quotes were requested from five vendors for computer hardware purchases. Three
responses were received. Two quotes met or exceeded the City's minimum configuration
and reliability standards for network equipment and one quote did not meet specification
due to the use of reconditioned equipment and was not certified by the State of Texas
Department of Information Resources contract. CDW-G, a DIR certified vendor,
submitted the lowest quote for the twenty-three Cisco Catalyst POE network switches in
the amount of $84,876.09. The 2011-12 adopted budget includes $85,000 for information
technology purchases of new and replacement equipment.
A motion by Councilman Robinson, a second by Councilman Froehlich, all voting "aye
approved Resolution No. 2011-071 authorizing the City Manager to purchase the
information technology equipment.
G.1 ADJOURNMENT.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tem Koch, a second by Councilwoman Holmes, all voting
"aye", adjourned the City Council meeting of October 18, 2011 at 7:23 p.m.
William P. Gla y, Mayor
Cindee Peters, City Secretary
Volume 105, page 13