2000-08-21 CC MinutesCITY OF FARMERS BRANCH
CITY COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING
August 21, 2000
COUNCIL CHAMBER
CITY HALL
7:30 P.M.
The following members of the City Council were present:
Mayor
Mayor Pro Tern
Councilmembers
Bob Phelps
Bill Moses
Calla Davis
Jim Robbs
Charlie Bird
Paul Walden
The following members of the City Administration were present:
City Manager
Assistant City Manager
Assistant City Manager
Assistant to City Manager
Assistant to City Manager
City Attorney
City Secretary
Communication Director
Economic Development Director
Director of Community Services
Director of Planning
City Engineer
Director of Finance
Director of Parks & Recreation
Director of Equipment Services
Library Director
Police Chief
Fire Chief
Director of Public Works
Traffic Engineer
Recording Secretary
Richard L. Escalante
Linda Groomer
John Burke
Margaret Somereve
John Roach
John Boyle
Cindee Peters
Tom Bryson
Norma Nichols
Michael Spicer
Kaizer Rangwala
Jerry Murawski
Charles Cox
Jeff Fuller
Don Moore
Mary Jane Stevenson
Jimmy Fawcett
Kyle King
Mark Pavageaux
Dave Davis
Suzanne Reynolds
Mayor Phelps called the City Council Meeting of August 21, 2000 to order at
7:35 P.M. The meeting was televised.
Volume 84, page 68
A.1 INVOCATION.
Councilman Bird gave the invocation and Mayor Pro Tern Moses led the
pledge of allegiance to the flag.
A.2 PRESENTATION OF SERVICE AWARDS.
Mayor Phelps presented a 10-year employee service award to Robin
Edwards of the Parks and Recreation Department.
Mayor Phelps presented a 15-year employee service award to Toribio
Martinez of the Public Works Department.
Mavor's Announcement
Tom Bryson, Communications Director, introduced Bodo Palte a
university student from Farmers Branch Sister City Garbsen, Germany
who will be interning with the City of Farmers Branch for approximately
eight weeks.
A.3 PRESENTATION OF BOARD APPLICATIONS.
There were no applications presented.
A. 4 REPORT ON STUDY SESSION ITEMS.
Mayor Phelps and the Council gave a brief summary of the items
discussed in Study Session prior to the Regular meeting.
B. CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING AS CONSENT ITEMS AND TAKE THE
APPROPRIATE ACTION B.1 - B.B.
Mayor Phelps stated consent items are items that are to be considered
and action taken that may not need discussion individually. Any member
of the City Council or the audience may request to withdraw any item
from the consent items and place the item before the Council for full
discussion. The concept for the consent items is established in order to
speed up discussion for those items that need more time for discussion.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Moses, seconded by Councilman Robbs, all
voting "aye," added Executive Session item E.1 a to Regular Agenda and
read item B.8 on the Consent Agenda.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Moses, seconded by Councilman Robbs, all
voting "aye," approved the Consent Agenda as amended.
Volume 84, page 69
B.1 APPROVED MINUTES OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST
7, 2000.
B.2 APPROVED MINUTES OF SPECIAL CITY COUNCIL OF AUGUST
14, 2000.
B.3 APPROVED THE REQUEST OF GNB TECHNOLOGIES, INC., FOR
SITE PLAN OF AN ADDITIONAL DUST COLLECTOR AND AN
APPROXIMATE 800 SQUARE FOOT MANUFACTURING
BUILDING EXPANSION ON 45.5 ACRES LOCATED AT 1880
VALLEY VIEW LANE WITHIN PLANNED DEVELOPMENT NO. 77.
B.4 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 2000-132 AWARDING THE BID
FOR TRAFFIC SIGNAL LOOP DETECTOR REPAIRS TO DURABLE
SPECIALTIES, INC.
B.5 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 2000-130 APPROVING AN
AMENDMENT TO THE ENGINEERING SERVICES CONTRACT
WITH ARS ENGINEERING, INC. FOR THE BROOKHAVEN CLUB
DRIVE RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT.
B.6 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 2000-125 AWARDING THE BIDS
FOR WATER METERS AND STRAINERS FOR THE PUBLIC
WORKS UTILITY DIVISION.
B.7 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 2000-128 ACCEPTING A FIVE-
FOOT AERIAL EASEMENT FOR STREET LIGHT INSTALLATION,
DEDICATED BY MR. AND MRS. ALFRED WOODALL OF 2964
TOPAZ LANE.
B.8 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 2000-127 AUTHORIZING THE
CONTINUATION OF THE HEALTH SERVICES AGREEMENT
BETWEEN DALLAS COUNTY AND THE CITY OF FARMERS
BRANCH.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. The City has
had a health services agreement with the Dallas County Health
Department for the past sixteen years. The agreement provides
that Dallas County will make certain communicable disease control
and laboratory health services available to Farmers Branch
residents. Communicable disease control and laboratory health
services are provided at 2377 N. Stemmons Freeway in Dallas.
The Dallas County Health Department conducts a well child clinic
two days per month at the City's Recreation Annex and conducts
Volume 84, page 70
a senior citizens clinic one day per month at the City's Senior
Center. Immunization services for Farmers Branch children are also
available four days per week at 1235 South Josey Lane in
Carrollton. The current agreement expires on September 30,
2000. The County Health Department has submitted a proposal
for continuation of these services for the fiscal year 2000-2001.
The total cost of services for fiscal year 2000-2001 will be
$14,853. The cost of the proposed contract is the same as the
cost of the current contract. Funds are proposed in the
Community Services Department budget for the health services
contract.
City staff recommends the City Manager be authorized to enter
into a health services agreement with Dallas County for the fiscal
year 2000-2001.
C.1 PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER THE REQUEST OF ZONE SYSTEMS,
INC., FOR SITE PLAN APPROVAL FOR SIX TELECOMMUNICATIONS
ANTENNA PANELS ON THE BUILDING FACADE OF THE RHD
HOSPITAL BUILDING AT 7 MEDICAL PARKWAY AND WITHIN THE
PLANNED DEVELOPMENT NO. 18 ZONING DISTRICT AND TAKE
APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. The applicant is
seeking site plan approval for installation of six telecommunications
antenna panels for Sprint PCS at the top of the building facade of the
RHD Hospital located at 7 Medical Parkway. Two of the proposed
antenna panels will be positioned on the north facade of the elevator
penthouse between two existing Metrocel antenna panels. The other
four proposed antenna panels are to be placed at the top of the building
facades at the southeast and southwest corners of the building. The
positioning of the antennas will not exceed the roofline of the penthouse
or the building parapet in their respective placements. The proposed
antennas shall be approximately the same size and color as the existing
Metrocel antenna panels mounted on the elevator penthouse wall.
Additionally, the applicant is proposing to install the antennas' associated
electrical and mechanical equipment cabinets on the roof of the building
with an access ladder to the penthouse roof. The associated equipment
attached to the building or penthouse wall will be painted the same color
as the respective wall.
Volume 84, page 71
The proposed site plan is consistent with the land use recommendations
of the Comprehensive Plan and complies with all PD-18 and
Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance regulations.
The Planning and Zoning Commission, by unanimous vote, recommends
approval of the site plan application subject to the rooftop plan view and
building elevations and the following conditions:
1 . The cable tray leading from the roof of the building to the roof of
the penthouse shall be painted to match the exterior of the
building.
2. Any antennas and associated equipment approved by the
proposed site plan shall be removed within 60 days of
discontinuance of operation.
Mayor Phelps opened the public hearing.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Moses, seconded Councilwoman Davis, all
voting "aye," closed the public hearing.
Councilman Walden asked if the service would better cover Farmers
Branch.
Peter Cavanaugh, 1620 Handly Drive, representing Sprint CPS, stated
there would be antennas located on the north side of the hospital, which
would improve the service in Farmers Branch. He stated it will not solve
all the problems but will solve some.
Mayor Phelps asked Mr. Cavanaugh if he was aware of the conditions.
Mr. Cavanaugh replied he was aware of the conditions and agreed with
them.
There being no further discussion, a motion by Councilwoman Davis,
seconded by Councilman Walden, all voting "aye", adopted Resolution
No. 2000-133 approving the site plan as recommended by the Planning
and Zoning Commission.
C.2 PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDER THE REQUEST OF SCOTT E. PARKER,
ON BEHALF OF J.B.'S CORVETTES, FOR APPROVAL OF SPECIFIC USE
PERMIT AND ASSOCIATED SITE PLAN FOR AN AUTOMOBILE
RESTORATION FACILITY, LOCATED AT 13211 BEE STREET, AND
WITHIN THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT NO. 70, OLD FARMERS
Volume 84, page 72
BRANCH GENERAL BUSINESS ZONING SUBDISTRICT AND TAKE
APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. The applicant
proposes an automobile restoration facility in an existing 8,250 square
foot building. The restoration work will include body repair, paint,
interior accessory installation, and cleaning and detailing of Corvettes.
There will be no engine repair performed.
All automobile repair operations and overnight storage of vehicles will be
inside the building. There will be no outdoor storage of salvaged
materials, junk vehicles or vehicle parts. Paint and chemical fumes will
be contained and small amounts of paint and chemicals used will be
stored inside the paint booth within the building, in accordance with the
environmental, building and fire codes.
Two special exceptions were granted by the Planning and Zoning
Commission to allow 16 instead of the required 20 parking spaces and to
allow 4 percent instead of the required 5 percent landscaping area. The
exceptions were granted because there are eight additional parking stalls
within the building and although the landscape area is limited to 4
percent, the applicant is proposing to plant the required trees and
shrubbery along Bee Street.
The Planning and Zoning Commission, by unanimous vote, recommends
approval of the Specific Use Permit and the associated site plan, with
special exceptions to landscaping area and parking space requirements,
with the following condition:
The proposed facility shall operate in strict compliance with the plan of
operation file-dated July 25, 2000.
Mayor Phelps opened the public hearing.
Mr. John Oechsner, 3509 Brookline Lane, stated he is in favor of this
request because he believes no capital expenditures would interfere with
the redevelopment of the area.
A motion by Councilman Bird, seconded by Councilman Walden, all
voting "aye," closed the public hearing.
Councilman Bird asked if there would be any motor repairs at this
location.
Volume 84, page 73
Scott Parker, 10 12 Elm Street, on behalf of John Bodnar, stated there
will be no motor repairs at this location.
Councilman Bird asked Mr. Parker if he was aware of the one condition
recommended by the Planning and Zoning Commission.
Mr. Parker replied yes he was aware of the condition and agreed with it.
There being no further discussion, a motion by Councilman Bird,
seconded by Councilman Walden, all voting "aye," adopted the following
captioned Ordinance No. 2558 approving the request for Specific Use
Permit and associated site plan, with the recommended condition of the
Planning and Zoning Commission.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH, TEXAS,
AMENDING THE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE
CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH, TEXAS, BY GRANTING A SPECIFIC
USE PERMIT TO ALLOW AN AUTOMOBILE RESTORATION
FACILITY, WITH SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS TO LANDSCAPING AREA
AND PARKING SPACE REQUIREMENTS, LOCATED AT 13211 BEE
STREET AND WITHIN THE PLANNED DEVELOPMENT NUMBER
70, GENERAL BUSINESS (PD-70, OFB-GB) ZONING DISTRICT;
PROVIDING FOR A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE; PROVIDING A
PENALTY OF FINE NOT TO EXCEED THE SUM OF TWO
THOUSAND ($2,000.00) DOLLARS; PROVIDING FOR
INJUNCTIVE RELIEF; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Mayor Phelps stated Executive Session item would be heard at this time.
E.1 a DISCUSS LAND ACQUISITIONS - TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE
SECTION 551.072
1. DISCUSS PURCHASE, SALE, LEASE, OR EXCHANGE OF
PROPERTY OWNED BY THE CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH AND
PROPERTY OWNED BY THE CARROLLTON-FARMERS BRANCH
INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR SCHOOL SITE
LOCATIONS AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps stated there were board members present who may be
involved in purchase, sale, lease, or exchange of property.
Mr. Escalante stated because of the significance of this issue that the
City Council wanted this matter to be discussed in open session. Mr.
Escalante briefly reviewed the proposal submitted by the School Board
Volume 84, page 74
concerning the trading of Farmers Branch park land for land at other
locations.
John Burke, Assistant City Manager, presented a review of events
beginning with the School District's bond issue and their intention to
build a K-5 elementary school in Farmers Branch.
Anne Coe, Athletic Coordinator, made a presentation showing the
current layout and multi-uses of the Farmers Branch Park practice
facility. She also presented charts that compared the proposed layout of
Farmers Branch Park as presented by the School Board. She reviewed
the decreased level of services that could be provided at this facility if
the School Board's proposal were approved.
Mr. Burke reviewed the additional cost to demolish the existing buildings
on a three-acre tract of land west of Farmers Branch Park on Josey Lane
and on Valley View Lane at Dennis Lane, the cost to redo the drainage in
the area, and to take out and reinstall the affected lighting and irrigation
at the park. The cost is estimated to be approximately $1.4 million.
Mr. Escalante stated the City has requested a final copy of the traffic
study around the site that the School District had prepared. Mr.
Escalante presented alternate school sites. He discussed the application
of eminent domain as it pertains to needs of a community through its
local government or an independent school district.
Mayor Phelps stated he and Mr. Escalante attended the School Board
meeting last week and were presented with a Resolution and have asked
for a response by September 15, 2000. The Mayor stated Council met
with staff and representatives of the Parks and Recreation Board and
various sports organizations on August 17, 2000, and with the School
Community Relations Committee on August 22, 2000. The Mayor
stated that it is the School Board's responsibility to build this school not
the City of Farmers Branch. The Mayor stated that he feels the Council
would provide the School Board with their decision before September 15,
2000.
Margaret Young, 3412 Highland Meadow, speaking on behalf of the
Parks and Recreation Board, stated that the board is charged with the
development and maintenance of the parks system in the City of Farmers
Branch. A responsibility they take great pride in. After studying the
School Board's proposal for Farmers Branch Park, the Parks and
Recreation Board does not feel this is a desirable use of this site.
Volume 84, page 75
Ms. Young stated this park is used by thousands of residents and
nonresidents throughout the year. A great deal of time and money has
been spent to turn the park into a first class athletic facility. Farmers
Branch has very little open space left for park development. She stated
the School Board's design does not offer a realistic use of space. She
stated the School's configuration takes away the multi use aspect of the
park. As an example, the reconfiguration would result in fields that
could only be used by small children eliminating fields for adults and
older youth. She also reviewed a safety concern of fields close to Josey
Lane and other fields that may be in use. Additionally, the increase in
traffic the school would generate would impact the traffic situation at
Mary Immaculate School. She stated that the design would drastically
reduce the fields for tournaments. In regard to the financial impact, she
stated that the City cannot ignore the amount of money already spent to
develop this park. She stated it would be unfair to the citizens to spend
additional funds to develop other parks.
Ms. Young stated that it would be unfair to take this park away from the
residents in the area. Therefore, the Parks and Recreation Board strongly
advises the Council to not relinquish this valuable park land. Farmers
Branch is the "City in the Park." The Board values that, and they ask
the Council to please not give it up.
Councilman Walden asked Mr. Fuller about the irrigation system at
Farmers Branch Park.
Mr. Fuller stated at the present time the 14-acre tract is irrigated and has
lighting and an extensive drainage system underneath that ties into the
alleyway on the north side of the park. He stated the lighting would
have to be moved and redirected and all irrigation would have to be
removed and reinstalled, as well as the drainage. He stated it would be
an extensive amount of work.
Mayor Phelps stated it would cost an estimated $1.5 million.
Mayor Phelps stated Citizen Participation would be moved up so citizens
could speak on the school issue or any other matter.
D.6 CITIZEN PARTICIPATION.
Margaret Young, 3412 Highland Meadow, stated she is a retired
schoolteacher and has four children. She stated she recognizes the need
and value of the education aspect of the children of Farmers Branch.
She stated she feels a new facility is long overdue and needed in
Farmers Branch. She commends the City, the Council, and the School
Volume 84, page 76
Board for pursuing this need and is confident that the best site will be
selected and the children will receive the quality of education they
deserve. However, she does not think the Farmers Branch Park is that
site and encourages the Council to seek another location for that facility.
Also she feels that Farmers Branch needs to remain "the City in the
Park".
Katie Roberts, 13240 Kerr Trail, representing the Senior Advisory Board,
stated they reviewed a portion of the video on June 5, 2000, where the
Carrollton-Farmers Branch Independent School District, requested
location of the park adjacent to the Senior Center. She stated the
Advisory Board reviewed the proposed school sites in Farmers Branch in
negotiations with the School District. Following a discussion at a
previous meeting, the Senior Advisory Board voted unanimously to
recommend to the City Council to reject the proposal as presented in the
video.
Ms. Roberts stated she received a letter from one of the residents of
Farmers Branch who has lived in that particular area for many years.
She stated in the letter he recalled there was a man that asked the City
Council for permission to put in a rent-subsidized apartment complex in
the undeveloped land on Dennis Lane behind the Post Office. She stated
many residents attended the City Council meeting and opposed the
development. The City Council denied the request and at the same
meeting it was requested by the residents that the City purchase the
land and develop it as a park with a walking and jogging track for all to
use. She stated it was acted on and the park was developed as
requested. She stated he feels this developed land is important to the
residents, as are all City facilities. This land serves a purpose to the
community of Farmers Branch, and in the letter the writer hopes the
Council will continue to honor the wishes made by the residents many
years ago to leave the park as it is. It has served the residents well and
will continue to do so if left intact.
Rod Duncan, 2857 Selma, representing Farmers Branch Youth Football
and Cheerleading spoke concerning the possible loss of the practice
fields at Farmers Branch Park, which is a multi-use field. He stated he
has been on the field along with hundreds of children practicing football
without being in the way of the softball and soccer teams practicing. He
stated under the School District's proposal, if his team was out on the
field, no one else could practice without endangering the children.
Mr. Duncan stated the field as it stands supports tournaments, and this
is important to be able to have a tournament and then return the field to
its general use. He emphasized the park is a community-used park,
Volume 84, page 77
residents can use it at anytime and the children of this community need
the park. He stated the School District is not very supportive of making
practice space available on their property. It is very difficult to schedule
the fields in advance.
Mr. Duncan stated he feels a school site at the Farmers Branch Park with
shared use from the School District would not be made available to the
children of the community. He stated the parks is not vacant and it is
inhabited daily and he strongly suggests that the City not allow this park
to be removed from the parks system in Farmers Branch.
Linda Ott, 2656 Wicker, read a letter from Phil Hunker, 3010
Longmeade, who became ill before the meeting. In his letter he stated
that he spent 40 years in baseball. The field layout will not work; it is
too small; 60 degrees will not cut it, unsafe, too crowded and too close.
He asked that his notes be read at the Council meeting. He represents
baseball and is against the proposed school site.
Ms. Ott stated she is very unhappy about this proposed school site. She
knows the schools are overcrowded and 50% of the children to attend
the proposed school would be from Carrollton. She stated she is
concerned about the City's After School Program because she knows the
Carrollton students would participate in the program, putting an added
strain on the City's program.
Ms. Ott stated the School District's bond program was voted on, and
she asked if it stated that Farmers Branch had to give up a park. She
stated she would like an answer from the Carrollton-Farmers Branch
School Board. She stated she would like to appeal to the citizens of
Farmers Branch to call the School Board and let them know how they
feel.
Ms. Ott stated she cannot justify taking the city park from the tax-paying
citizens of Farmers Branch and expects the Council not to take this park
away from the citizens. She stated after viewing the plans on the
proposed school site, she feels it is not feasible to fit all the leagues on
the field.
Ms. Ott stated again that she wants the Council to represent her
concerns as a taxpayer.
Donna Albritton, 13629 Charcoal, stated she walks around the field at
the park daily and enjoys watching the different sports taking place. She
stated she would like for the park to stay the same.
Volume 84, page 78
C.3 PUBLIC HEARING: TO CONSIDER RESCINDING ORDINANCE NO. 2515
AND ADOPTING ORDINANCE NO. 2559 RELATIVE TO FARMERS
BRANCH YOUTH PROGRAMS' STANDARDS OF CARE IN
COMPLIANCE WITH 1995 SENATE BILL 212 AND TAKE APPROPRIATE
ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. During the 1995
legislative session, State Legislators enacted Senate Bill 212, exempting
certain youth recreation programs from childcare licensing requirements.
Senate Bill 212 exempts youth recreation programs operated by a
municipality provided the governing body of the municipality annually
adopts standards of care by ordinance after a public hearing. There are
no changes in the proposed ordinance from the existing ordinance.
The Parks and Recreation Director recommends rescinding Ordinance No.
2515 and adopting Ordinance No. 2559 relative to Farmers Branch youth
programs' Standards of Care in compliance with 1995 Senate Bill 212.
Mayor Phelps opened the public hearing.
A motion by Mayor Pro Tern Moses, seconded by Councilman Robbs, all
voting "aye," closed the public hearing.
There being no discussion, a motion by Councilman Robbs, seconded by
Councilman Walden, all voting "aye," rescinded Ordinance No. 2515 and
adopted the following captioned Ordinance No. 2559.
AN ORDINANCE RESCINDING ORDINANCE NO. 2515 AND
ADOPTING ORDINANCE NO. 2554 COVERING STANDARDS OF
CARE FOR THE CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH YOUTH PROGRAMS.
D.1 CONSIDER ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 2000-134 SUPPORTING THE
PASSAGE OF ENABLING LEGISLATION FOR PHOTOGRAPHIC RED
LIGHT ENFORCEMENT IN THE 77TH TEXAS LEGISLATURE AND TAKE
APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. The disregard of
traffic signals causes 260,000 accidents annually in the United States,
according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. This
disregard of red lights accounts for twenty-two percent of all motor
vehicle crashes, making it the largest single cause. According to the
most recent Texas Department of Public Safety statistics in Texas in
1998, disregarding a red light or stop sign accounted for 28,019
accidents of which 191 resulted in fatalities.
Volume 84, page 79
A traffic survey conducted in Dallas County in 1999 found that one red
light violation occurred every two minutes during peak traffic periods and
a violation occurred on a daily average every five minutes.
Photographic traffic signal enforcement techniques have been used
worldwide for over forty years. Currently in the United States ten states
have laws that permit photographic enforcement and the statistics from
these states show that the number of red light accidents and fatalities
have been significantly reduced since these laws were enacted.
Staff recommends adopting Resolution No. 2000-134 supporting the
passage of enabling legislation for photographic traffic signal
enforcement in the 77th Texas Legislature.
Mayor Phelps asked the Police Chief to comment on this issue.
Jimmy Fawcett, Chief of Police, stated this item is a high legislative
priority for the Texas Police Chiefs Association. It is an issue that has
drawn national attention and has received much support. With
resolutions from municipalities around the state there is a better chance
of getting this passed by the legislature.
Councilman Walden asked about the red light enforcement.
Chief Fawcett stated in the last five years the North Texas Police Chiefs
Association has worked with 27 municipalities in North Texas in a
program to strictly enforce red lights for a 30-day period. In the 30-day
period in June 2000, Farmers Branch issued 400 citations for red-light
violations. Chief Fawcett stated enforcement can be done but is very
costly to the City. He stated the use of photographic equipment is
more cost effective.
Mayor Phelps asked if any cities in the area were using the equipment.
Chief Fawcett replied not in Texas or surrounding states. New York
was one of the first states to allow photographic equipment. He stated
it was also very effective.
Councilman Walden asked how this process worked.
Chief Fawcett stated the enabling legislature sets up a new way of
enforcing the running of red lights. He stated at certain intersections of
the City, photographic equipment is set up and when someone runs the
red light a photograph of the license plate is taken. The owner of the
Volume 84, page 80
vehicle is notified about the running of the red light. Chief Fawcett
stated it is like parking tickets, you file on the car not the operator, then
there are fines levied against the vehicle.
Councilman Walden stated then is there an opportunity to state that
you were not driving the vehicle.
Chief Fawcett replied the legislation taken before the Legislature would
allow the owner of the vehicle to inform the court who was driving
their vehicle that day. Chief Fawcett did state the ultimate
responsibility lies with the owner.
There being no further discussion, a motion by Councilman Bird,
seconded by Councilwoman Davis, all voting "aye," adopted Resolution
No. 2000-134 supporting the passage of enabling legislation for
photographic traffic signal enforcement in the 77th Texas Legislature.
D.2 CONSIDER ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 2000-088 AUTHORIZING
THE CITY MANAGER TO APPLY FOR AND ADMINISTER THE 1999/
2000 FEDERAL BUREAU OF JUSTICE ASSISTANCE BLOCK GRANT
AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. The Federal Bureau
of Justice makes funds available to local law enforcement agencies in
the form of a noncompetitive block grant. The amount of the grant is
based on a formula that takes into account current and past crime rates,
population and other factors. The City of Farmers Branch is eligible for
$20,940.00 in funds through this program. These funds may be used to
purchase law enforcement equipment and pay overtime for specific
projects related to local law enforcement. The City is required to match
the grant with the amount of $2,327.00. The Chief of Police has
proposed taking the required amount of $2,327.00 from the seized funds
account for this match.
The Police Department proposes to use these funds to purchase a bicycle
and all associated equipment necessary to fully outfit an additional
bicycle officer. The Department has applied for and been given funding
for an additional officer through the "COPS" program. The balance of
money will be used to upgrade or replace existing equipment and to pay
overtime for special assignments for the bicycle unit.
Before the funds are released to the local agency, a resolution must be
passed by the City Council authorizing the City Manager to apply for and
administer the grant. Additionally, provisions of the grant require the
Volume 84, page 81
public be made aware of and have input in the proposed use of the grant
in a City Council meeting.
Staff recommends adopting Resolution No. 2000-088 authorizing the
City Manager to apply for the Federal Bureau of Justice Assistance
Block Grant.
There being no discussion a motion by Councilman Walden, seconded
by Councilwoman Davis, all voting "aye," adopted Resolution No.
2000-088 authorizing the City Manager to apply for the Federal Bureau
of Justice Assistance Block Grant.
D.3 CONSIDER ADOPTING ORDINANCE NO. 2498 ESTABLISHING A
MUNICIPAL COURT OF RECORD; PROVIDING A SAVINGS CLAUSE;
PROVIDING A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. Ordinance No. 2498
provides that the governing body of the City of Farmers Branch will
establish their municipal court as a municipal court of record.
The benefits of a municipal court of record are found in the additional
authorities granted to the court and municipal court judge as well as
expediting the process by which criminal, traffic, and especially code
violations, are adjudicated. As allowed by state law, the judge of a
municipal court of record has the authority to sign evidentiary search
warrants, and may issue writs and attachments as well as endorse
warrants issued by the mayor to allow the warrants to be executed
throughout the state.
In a Municipal Court of Record, a motion for a new trial must set forth
the points of error within the trial proceedings. Therefore, establishing
the Municipal Court as a court of record will allow the City to provide a
more efficient disposition of appeal cases.
Staff recommends establishing the Municipal Court as a Municipal Court
of Record.
Mayor Phelps stated currrently a traffic ticket could be appealed to the
County Court and if they are fined, the dollars go to County Court not
the City. The City does all the work and receives no monies. Mayor
Phelps stated the City is looking forward to the establishment of a
Municipal Court of Records.
Volume 84, page 82
Mr. Escalante stated the Chief of Police has placed some very positive
issues on this agenda. He stated this particular issue would allow for a
fair administration of justice in matters involving the Police Department.
He stated the City is repeatedly asked to enforce the building codes and
property maintenance codes, and usually citations are issued. The judge
finds the property owner guilty, based on evidence, and the property
owner often appeals.
Mr. Escalante stated establishing a Court of Record will provide for
appeal procedures based on matters of law, which will allow for
improved and more effective administration of justice and bring an
appropriate resolution for the City.
Mayor Phelps stated the only way an appeal could be held out of this
court is if there was an error by the judge or prosecutor.
John Boyle, City Attorney, stated an appeal under the current law is an
appeal of de novo where the appellant gets a second bite of the apple.
In a Court of Record unless there is an error in the application of the law,
there is no appeal. In a Court of Record, the number of appeals is very
small.
There being no further discussion, a motion by Councilman Robbs,
seconded by Councilman Bird, all voting "aye," adopted the following
captioned Ordinance No. 2498 establishing a Municipal Court of Record.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH,
ESTABLISHING MUNICIPAL COURT OF RECORD NO. 1,
PROVIDING A REPEALING CLAUSE, PROVIDING A SEVERABILITY
CLAUSE, AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
D.4 CONSIDER ADOPTING RESOLUTION NO. 2000-126 AWARDING BIDS
AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO
CONTRACTS FOR EMPLOYEE BENEFITS AND TAKE APPROPRIATE
ACTION.
Mayor Phelps presented the following information. The City offers an
employee benefit plan with various benefit options. The plan provides
core benefits including: Major Medical, Life and Accidental Death &
Dismemberment, Long-Term Disability, and optional additional benefit
coverages. City employees are responsible for paying a portion of the
dependent medical coverage. Contracts for the employee benefit
package expire on September 30, 2000.
Volume 84, page 83
Eighteen bids were received and opened on July 12, 2000. The bids
were evaluated by the Human Resources Department with the assistance
of Wethe & Associates, an independent benefits consultant.
Staff recommends LifeRe for dental insurance and Flexible Spending
Account Administration; Group Life & Health Division of Fort Dearborn
Life Insurance Company for Long-Term Disability and Basic and
Voluntary Accidental Death and Dismemberment; and Vision Service Plan
for vision coverage. All recommended contracts meet or exceed current
benefit levels. The budget amount in the proposed 2000-2001 budget is
$2,165,000.
The Human Resources Director recommends adopting Resolution No.
2000-126 authorizing the City Manager to enter into contracts for
employee benefits.
There being no further discussion, a motion by Councilman Walden,
seconded by Councilwoman Davis, all voting "aye," adopted Resolution
No. 2000-126 authorizing the City Manager to enter into contracts for
employee benefits.
D.5 CONSIDER COUNCIL TRAVEL REPORTS AND REQUESTS AND TAKE
THE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
There were no travel reports or requests.
MAYOR PHELPS ANNOUNCED THAT THE ITEMS ON THE AGENDA FOR THE
EXECUTIVE SESSION WERE DISCUSSED IN THE 3:30 P.M. WORK SESSION.
MAYOR PHELPS EXPLAINED THE CITY COUNCIL CONVENED INTO
EXECUTIVE SESSION AT 3:31 P.M. AND CONCLUDED AT 4:22 P.M..
TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE CHAPTER 551 OF THE OPEN MEETING LAW
PROVIDES THAT SUCH ITEMS AS PERSONNEL MATTERS, LAND
ACQUISITION AND PENDING AND CONTEMPLATED LITIGATION MAY BE
DISCUSSED IN CLOSED SESSION.
E.1 a DISCUSS LAND ACQUISITIONS - TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE
SECTION 551.072
1. DISCUSS PURCHASE, SALE, LEASE, OR EXCHANGE OF
PROPERTY OWNED BY THE CITY OF FARMERS BRANCH AND
PROPERTY OWNED BY THE CARROLLTON-FARMERS BRANCH
INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR SCHOOL SITE
LOCATIONS AND TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps explained Staff discussed this item with the City Council.
Volume 84, page 84
E.1 b DISCUSS PENDING AND CONTEMPLATED LITIGATION - TEXAS
GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 551.071
1. DISCUSS LITIGATION RELATIVE TO R.C. SMALL AND AN
AGREEMENT WITH R.C. SMALL AND ASSOCIATES, INC. AND
TAKE APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Mayor Phelps explained Staff discussed this item with the City
Council.
E.2 CONSIDER NECESSARY ACTION ON ITEMS DISCUSSED IN THE
EXECUTIVE SESSION.
Mayor Phelps stated the City Council was updated on the Carrollton-
Farmers Branch Independent School District school site location. No
action was necessary.
Mayor Phelps stated the City Council was updated on litigation relative
to R. C. Small and Associates. No action was necessary.
F.1 ADJOURNMENT.
A motion by Councilman Bird, a second by Councilman Robbs, all
voting "aye", adjourned the City Council meeting of August 21, 2000
at 9:22 P.M.
24
Mayor
City Secretary
Volume 84, page 85